Skip to content

Gage & Tollner

372 Fulton St. · Brooklyn

#98 42 Up 42 places from #140 last week

2 votes

Gage & Tollner is tied for #98 this week. One more vote breaks the tie!

Gage & Tollner
  • Last week 140th
  • Two weeks ago 36th
  • Three weeks ago 36th

Voting closes in 0d 12h 3m

Facts

Name
Gage & Tollner
Address
372 Fulton St.
City
Brooklyn
State
New York
Country
United States

Share

Gage & Tollner

Gage & Tollner's rich history is as captivating as its mouthwatering menu. Originally opened as a chop house, the restaurant quickly gained a reputation for its exceptional seafood and steaks. Its elegant Victorian-style interior, complete with intricate woodwork, stained glass, and vintage fixtures, transports guests to a bygone era of opulence and charm.

Gage & Tollner's menu is a testament to culinary excellence. Led by an accomplished team of chefs, the restaurant combines traditional techniques with contemporary flair to create a dining experience that is both nostalgic and innovative. From the moment you peruse the menu, you'll be enticed by an array of tantalizing options, including fresh oysters, succulent lobster, perfectly cooked steaks, and an array of vegetarian and vegan delights.

What sets Gage & Tollner apart is its unwavering commitment to impeccable service and attention to detail. From the warm greeting at the door to the knowledgeable and attentive staff, every aspect of the dining experience is carefully curated to ensure that guests feel welcome and pampered. The sommelier is on hand to guide you through an extensive wine list, expertly pairing each dish with the perfect vintage, enhancing the flavors and creating a harmonious dining experience.

Step inside Gage & Tollner, and you'll be transported to a world of refined elegance. The restaurant's meticulously restored interior is a sight to behold, with its ornate chandeliers, plush velvet banquettes, and polished mahogany bar. The soft glow of candlelight casts a warm ambiance, creating an intimate setting perfect for special occasions or romantic evenings.

Beyond its culinary prowess, Gage & Tollner is deeply committed to supporting the local community and embracing sustainable practices. The restaurant actively sources ingredients from local farmers, fishermen, and purveyors, ensuring that each dish is crafted with the freshest, highest quality ingredients. By prioritizing sustainability, Gage & Tollner not only offers exceptional cuisine but also plays a vital role in preserving the environment for future generations.

Gage & Tollner stands as a testament to the rich culinary heritage of Brooklyn, captivating guests with its timeless charm, exquisite flavors, and impeccable service. Whether you're seeking a nostalgic dining experience or simply craving an unforgettable meal, this historic restaurant will undoubtedly exceed your expectations. Gage & Tollner has etched its name as an iconic destination, where culinary excellence and historic charm come together to create an experience that is truly unforgettable.

Ranking history

Best place ever

#140

once, last in week 44, 2026

Weeks in top 10

0

Weeks ranked

1

weeks with at least one vote

Final place per week, last 10 weeks. Shaded: top 10, gaps: weeks without votes, gold dots: weeks won.

Show as table
WeekPlace
Week 53, 2026 No votes
Week 52, 2026 No votes
Week 51, 2026 No votes
Week 50, 2026 No votes
Week 49, 2026 No votes
Week 48, 2026 No votes
Week 47, 2026 No votes
Week 46, 2026 No votes
Week 45, 2026 No votes
Week 44, 2026 #140

Who wins this week?

Think Gage & Tollner finishes #1 this week? Pick it in the prediction game for up to 30 points.

Pick Gage & Tollner to win

Follow Gage & Tollner

Every Monday: Gage & Tollner’s place in last week’s ranking, in one short email. No account needed.

More restaurants like Gage & Tollner

Linked to Gage & Tollner on other lists

Everything from United States this week →

Are you Gage & Tollner? Put this on your site

Add this badge to your website: it shows this week's place, updates itself and takes your fans straight to the vote.

Are you Gage & Tollner? Put this on your site

Is this your page?

Are you the official account or a representative of Gage & Tollner? Claim this page for free and get the verified tick.

Claim this page

Free verification · Pro for your own description, statistics and no ads

Your involvement

If you notice any errors in the information or photos, or if you have suggestions for improvements, please feel free to submit them through the support form. Business: ask.oftheweek@gmail.com

Theme

Pick a list

Places

Sport

People

Movies, music & more

Cars, pets & days

All lists

Ask your friends to vote too:

Don't forget that you can always vote again after one hour of voting. See all your votes and your streak →